Project-based and task-based learning in CLIL: how to design projects in English
Project-based learning (PBL) and task-based language teaching (TBLT) fit naturally with CLIL: in both, pupils use language to do something meaningful, not to practise language for its own sake. They are close cousins, but they aren't the same, and it helps to know when to use each.
Task or project: the difference
| Task (TBLT) | Project (PBL) | |
|---|---|---|
| Length | One or a few lessons | Several weeks |
| Starting point | A specific communicative need | An open question or challenge |
| Outcome | A concrete result: a decision, a plan, a list | A final product for a real audience |
| Example | Planning the menu for a class trip in pairs | Making a guide to our neighbourhood for visitors |
A useful way to see it: a project is made of tasks. Tasks are the bricks; the project is the building.
Task-based learning
N. S. Prabhu was one of the first to propose it in the 1980s, and Jane Willis organised it into a framework that is still the most practical:
- Pre-task: introduce the topic and the task, activate vocabulary and, if possible, show an example of the expected outcome.
- Task cycle:
- Task: pupils work in pairs or groups to reach the outcome.
- Planning: they prepare how they will report what they did.
- Report: they present it to the class.
- Language focus: only at the end does the teacher collect the language that came up, correct the most important points and practise anything that was missing.
The interesting part is the order: use the language first and work on form afterwards, the opposite of a traditional lesson.
Example task for ages 9–10: each pair has half the information about two animals (habitat, diet, size). Without showing each other their sheets, they ask questions to complete a table and decide which animal would make a better class pet. It's an information gap task: they need to talk in English to solve it.
Project-based learning
A high-quality project usually has these elements, set out in PBLWorks' Gold Standard PBL model:
- A challenging problem or question.
- Sustained inquiry: investigating, asking questions and finding information over several lessons.
- Authenticity: a connection with the real world or with pupils' interests.
- Student voice and choice over part of the process or the product.
- Reflection on what they learn and how they learn it.
- Critique and revision based on feedback from others.
- A public product: something presented or delivered to someone outside the class.
Complete example: “Welcome to our town!” (ages 9–10)
Driving question: How can we help visitors discover our town?
Final product: an illustrated guide in English to the neighbourhood or town (a leaflet or map), presented to families and handed, for example, to the local tourist office or library.
| Phase | Lessons | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Launch | 1 | An imaginary tourist writes to the class asking for help. What can we tell him about our town? |
| Investigation | 2–4 | In groups, each investigates one type of place: parks, monuments, shops, services. A walk around the area with photos and notes. |
| Making the product | 5–7 | Each group writes its section with sentence frames: In our town there is… You can… It's open from… |
| Revision | 8 | Groups swap sections: each one reads another group's section and gives one suggestion for improvement. |
| Presentation | 9 | Presentation to families and delivery of the guide. |
Social Science content: places and services in the local area, maps, finding your way. Language: there is / there are, can for possibilities, prepositions of place, opening times. Culture: our own place explained to someone from outside.
The CLIL lesson planner can turn a driving question like this into a full unit plan with a sequence, sentence frames and a rubric.
Organising group work
- Roles with language: leader, secretary, timekeeper and spokesperson, each with their own phrases. The role cards in the classroom display maker are designed for this.
- Checkpoints: set dates to review progress instead of waiting until the end.
- Project diary: each lesson ends with an exit ticket: what we did, what we will do tomorrow, what we need.
Common mistakes
- Confusing a project with a final craft activity. If all the learning happens beforehand and the “project” is just making a display at the end, it isn't PBL.
- A product with no audience. A product only the teacher sees loses much of its purpose.
- Forgetting the language. In CLIL you need to plan which structures each phase will require and what support you will give, as in any other lesson.
- Assessing only the final product. The process (inquiry, collaboration, revision) matters as much as the result. The CLIL rubric maker has a project task type with criteria for both.
Further reading
- Willis, J. (1996). A Framework for Task-Based Learning. Longman.
- Prabhu, N. S. (1987). Second Language Pedagogy. Oxford University Press.
- Ellis, R. (2003). Task-based Language Learning and Teaching. Oxford University Press.
- Larmer, J., Mergendoller, J. and Boss, S. (2015). Setting the Standard for Project Based Learning. ASCD.