How to plan a CLIL unit around a challenge (with a worked example for ages 8–9)

A good CLIL unit is not a list of activities on a topic. It is a set of connected tasks driven by a challenge or question that makes sense to pupils, ending in a final product that shows what they have learnt. In CLIL, that challenge is solved using the additional language, so the language is a tool for getting something done, not the goal in itself.

A structure in six parts

  1. Context and challenge. A real or believable situation: “Our school garden looks sad: what do our plants need to grow?”
  2. Final product. What pupils will create: an illustrated guide, an exhibition, a video, a reported experiment.
  3. Objectives and curriculum links. What pupils should know and be able to do, linked to the objectives or standards of your own curriculum for each subject involved.
  4. The 4Cs. Content, communication (language of, for and through learning), cognition and culture. See the 4Cs of CLIL.
  5. Sequence of activities. Activation, investigation, making the product and sharing it.
  6. Assessment. Tools linked to the objectives: a rubric, a checklist, self-assessment.

Shortcut: the CLIL lesson planner follows this same structure and builds a printable plan with the 4Cs, sentence frames, a five-phase sequence, scaffolding and an integrated rubric.

A topic or a challenge?

Compare these two openings:

  • A: “Pupils will learn the types of vertebrates and their features.”
  • B: “A local animal shelter has asked for our help: new animals are arriving, and they need fact cards in English for volunteers who come from other countries. Can we make them?”

The content is the same, but B gives pupils a reason to learn: it starts from a context they can imagine as real, sets a challenge and ends in a product with an audience. Before you settle on your unit, check three things:

  1. Does it start from a concrete context that pupils recognise or could come across?
  2. Is it framed as a question, a problem or a challenge to solve?
  3. Does the final product have an audience or a use beyond the exercise book?

Where to find the challenge

If you struggle to find a starting point, these sources work well in primary:

  • Something pupils bring: a minibeast found in the playground, a question someone asked in class.
  • A phenomenon you can observe: how shadows in the playground change during the day, why windows steam up.
  • A local problem: the playground is messy after break, the school garden produces no tomatoes.
  • A request from an expert or the community: the local librarian wants book recommendations, the vet needs posters for the waiting room.
  • A question about the world: Is there life on Mars? Can we live without bees?
  • A work of art: a painting, a song or a building that sparks curiosity.

A simple tip: write the title as a question or challenge, in pupils' own words. Can we save the bees? hooks a class far more than Pollinating insects.

Plan backwards

Wiggins and McTighe's backward design puts three steps in this order: first decide what you want pupils to learn, then how they will show it (the product and its assessment), and only then choose the activities. It avoids a very common trap: lots of attractive activities that don't lead anywhere.

Example: “Help our school garden!” (ages 8–9)

Challenge: the plants in the school garden aren't growing. The class investigates what plants need and makes an illustrated plant care guide in English, which they present to a younger class.

Final product: Our Plant Care Guide, a poster or small book made in groups, with instructions and drawings.

Objectives:

  • Science: identify the parts of a plant and what plants need to grow (light, water, air, soil), and carry out a simple fair test.
  • Language: understand and give simple instructions (Water them every…), make predictions (I predict…) and describe results.

Link these to the matching objectives in your own curriculum: the structure of the unit stays the same whatever system you teach in.

Sequence (8 lessons)

Phase Lessons Activities
Activation 1 Visit to the garden. What can you see? Is it healthy? Brainstorm with pictures.
Vocabulary 2 Picture dictionary of the parts of a plant and what plants need. Flashcard games.
Investigation 3–5 Group experiment: plants with and without light, with and without water. Predictions with I predict… and a weekly record.
Making the product 6–7 Writing the guide with sentence frames: Plants need… Water them every…
Sharing 8 Presenting the guides to a younger class, explaining with visual support.

The phases of deeper learning

The pluriliteracies approach organises a sequence into deeper learning episodes with five phases. They fit the table above and help you not to skip anything:

  1. Activation: spark interest and find out what pupils already know (the garden visit).
  2. First contact with new knowledge: understand the basic ideas and show it in a first simple product (the picture dictionary).
  3. Consolidation: practise and go deeper through several tasks and products (the experiment and the record).
  4. Transfer: apply what they have learnt to a new situation (a guide for other plants around the school).
  5. Review: look back on what they have learnt and how they learnt it (the final self-assessment).

Between phases there is feedback: pupils know what went well and what they can improve before moving on.

Assessment

  • A rubric for the final product with separate rows for content (what plants need) and communication (instructions in English). The CLIL rubric maker prepares one in a minute; see also assessment in CLIL.
  • A checklist during the experiment (makes predictions, records data).
  • A final self-assessment: I can name the parts of a plant. I can explain what plants need.

Materials you can make for this unit

The “Plants (Science)” theme in the vocabulary bank includes the key words. With one click you can make the picture dictionary, a revision crossword and a quiz for the start and the end of the unit.

Further reading

  • Wiggins, G. and McTighe, J. (2005). Understanding by Design (2nd ed.). ASCD.
  • Meyer, O. and Coyle, D. (2017). Pluriliteracies Teaching for Learning: conceptualizing progression for deeper learning in literacies development. European Journal of Applied Linguistics, 5(2).
  • Ball, P., Kelly, K. and Clegg, J. (2015). Putting CLIL into Practice. Oxford University Press.
  • Coyle, D., Hood, P. and Marsh, D. (2010). CLIL: Content and Language Integrated Learning. Cambridge University Press.