Scaffolding in CLIL: types of support, examples and how to remove it

Scaffolding means giving pupils temporary support so they can do a task they couldn't yet do on their own. Like scaffolding on a building, it has two features: it goes up so that something can be built, and it comes down when the structure stands by itself. Support that is never removed stops being scaffolding and becomes dependence.

In CLIL, scaffolding works twice over: you scaffold the content (which is new) and the language (which is not the pupils' first language), often at the same time.

Types of scaffolding

Visual

  • Pictures and flashcards for every key word.
  • Graphic organisers: classification tables, Venn diagrams, timelines, concept maps.
  • Real objects and demonstrations (realia): one real plant is worth more than three slides.
  • Short videos with the sound off, narrated by the teacher in adapted language.

Linguistic

  • Word banks visible during the task.
  • Sentence frames: A… is a vertebrate because it has got…
  • Sentence starters: I think…, In my opinion…, First…, then…
  • Picture glossaries that pupils build throughout the unit.
  • Adapted texts: short sentences, highlighted vocabulary, one idea per paragraph.

Interactive

  • Pair work before speaking to the whole class (think, pair, share).
  • Cooperative roles with a clear language function (the one who asks, the one who notes, the one who explains).
  • Teacher recasts: a pupil says Plant… water… no, and the teacher gives back Yes! The plant has got no water, so it dies.

Helping is not the same as scaffolding

The difference is subtle but important. Helping means solving it for the pupil: if they write elefant, you correct the word. Scaffolding means giving just enough for them to solve it: Listen: ele-PHANT. Which letters make the /f/ sound? Check the word bank. In the first case the teacher does the task; in the second, the pupil does it with support, and next time will need less.

Three levels of scaffolding

Scaffolding is not only what you say in the moment. It is planned at three levels:

  • Unit: the sequence moves from concrete to abstract and from single words to texts; each lesson builds on the previous one.
  • Activity: each task comes with its support already designed: word bank, sentence frame, table to complete, worked example.
  • Interaction: what happens in the room: recasting, asking a simpler question, pointing to a picture, giving more wait time.

Six scaffolding strategies (Aída Walqui)

Walqui describes six types of strategy. This is how they look in a primary classroom:

Strategy What it involves Example
Modelling Showing how before asking for it The teacher describes their favourite animal aloud before pupils do it.
Bridging Starting from what pupils already know What animals have you got at home? before classifying animals.
Contextualising Making content accessible with pictures, objects or gestures Bringing a real plant; a silent video narrated by the teacher.
Schema building Helping to organise ideas A concept map or classification table completed together.
Re-presenting text Turning information into another format Turning a text about the water cycle into a labelled drawing, or a drawing into three sentences.
Developing metacognition Thinking about how they learn What helped you today? What was difficult? at the end of the lesson.

Scaffolding and Universal Design for Learning

Universal Design for Learning (UDL, from CAST) fits naturally with CLIL. It proposes offering, from the design stage and for the whole class, several ways to engage with the task, to access the information and to express what has been learnt. In a CLIL lesson, that means presenting content with a picture, a text and an object at the same time, and accepting that someone can show they know how to classify animals with a labelled drawing instead of a paragraph.

The difference is one of focus: UDL builds the options in before barriers appear, while scaffolding adjusts support to each pupil as they learn. Used together, they greatly reduce the need for later individual adaptations.

Example: describing animals (ages 6–7)

Stage Scaffolding What pupils do
Start Flashcards + word bank + It has got… frame on the board Describe an animal by reading the frame
Middle Word bank only Describe an animal with the word bank
End No written support, pictures only Guessing game: describe an animal for the others to guess

How to remove support

  1. Plan it from the start: decide which support you will remove and when.
  2. Remove one thing at a time: first the complete sentence frame, then leave only the starter, then only the key words.
  3. Observe before removing: if most pupils still depend on the support, keep it for the class and remove it only for those who no longer need it.
  4. Keep support available but out of sight: for example, the word bank in an envelope on the table.

Tools that help you scaffold

Further reading

  • Wood, D., Bruner, J. and Ross, G. (1976). The role of tutoring in problem solving. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 17(2).
  • Walqui, A. (2006). Scaffolding instruction for English language learners: a conceptual framework. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 9(2).
  • Hammond, J. and Gibbons, P. (2005). Putting scaffolding to work: the contribution of scaffolding in articulating ESL education. Prospect, 20(1).
  • Mehisto, P., Marsh, D. and Frigols, M. J. (2008). Uncovering CLIL. Macmillan.
  • CAST (2024). Universal Design for Learning Guidelines version 3.0. udlguidelines.cast.org