The 4Cs of CLIL: Content, Communication, Cognition and Culture with examples
The 4Cs framework, proposed by Do Coyle, is the most useful tool for planning a CLIL lesson. It works as a checklist: if one of the four Cs is missing, the lesson limps.
1. Content
The knowledge and skills of the subject: what plants need, how to classify an animal, how primary colours mix. Content leads: the language is there to serve learning it, not the other way round.
Planning question: what should pupils know and be able to do by the end?
2. Communication
The language pupils need to learn that content. Coyle divides it into three:
- Language of learning: the topic vocabulary and structures (root, leaf, Plants need…).
- Language for learning: the language to take part: comparing, explaining, asking for help, working in a group (I think…, Do you agree?, Can you help me?).
- Language through learning: language that emerges during the task and wasn't planned; the teacher picks it up and gives it back.
Planning question: what do they need to say or write, and what support do they need to do it?
Planning it in three steps (Coyle's 3As):
- Analyse: go through the content and note the key words and expressions without which it can't be understood (language of).
- Add: add the language they will need to do the tasks and interact: asking, comparing, giving a reason (language for). This is also where you decide on the support.
- Apply: during the lesson, collect the new language that comes up and build on it (language through). A “new words” corner on the board keeps it from getting lost.
3. Cognition
The thinking processes the task requires. A lesson that only asks pupils to remember (name the parts) stays at what Bloom's taxonomy calls lower-order thinking skills (LOTS). To reach higher-order thinking skills (HOTS), you need to ask pupils to compare, classify, explain causes, predict or create.
Planning question: what do they have to do with the content, beyond remembering it?
Questions for each level of Bloom's taxonomy
Anderson and Krathwohl's revised taxonomy (2001) orders six processes from least to most demanding. These simple questions raise the level without making the language harder:
| Level | What it asks for | Questions for primary |
|---|---|---|
| Remember | Name, point, repeat | What is this? Can you point to the root? |
| Understand | Explain in their own words, describe | What does a plant need? Can you tell me why? |
| Apply | Use what they learnt in a new case | Where would you put this plant? What would you do? |
| Analyse | Compare, classify, find differences | What's the difference between these two plants? Which group does it go in? |
| Evaluate | Choose and justify | Which is the best place for our plant? Why do you think so? |
| Create | Design, invent, propose | Can you design a pot for a plant that lives in the desert? |
A good habit: before teaching a lesson, check that at least one question or task belongs to the last three levels.
Cognitive discourse functions
Christiane Dalton-Puffer proposed a very practical bridge between thinking and language: cognitive discourse functions, what we do with language when we think about content. There are seven: classify, define, describe, evaluate, explain, explore and report. Each one has its typical language, which is worth giving to pupils:
- Classify: It's a… because it has got… / It goes in this group because…
- Define: A mammal is an animal that…
- Describe: It's big and grey. It has got four legs.
- Explain: The plant died because it had no water.
- Evaluate: I think this one is better because…
- Explore (hypothesise): I predict that… / Maybe it will…
- Report: First we…, then we…, finally we…
If you know which function a task requires, you know which sentence frames to prepare. The sentence frames cards are organised by exactly these functions.
4. Culture
The dimension that connects learning with the world: other cultures, the local community and the sense of being part of something bigger. In science, it can be comparing plants from different parts of the world; in art, getting to know artists from other countries.
Planning question: which people, places or realities does this learning connect with?
A complete example: “What do plants need?” (ages 8–9)
| C | Plan |
|---|---|
| Content | The parts of a plant and what it needs to live (water, light, air, soil). |
| Communication | Of: root, stem, leaf, flower, seed, soil. For: “Plants need…”, “I predict that…”, “The plant with… grows more because…”. |
| Cognition | Predict which plant will grow more in an experiment (with and without light, with and without water) and explain the result. |
| Culture | Compare plants from a dry climate (cactus) and a wet one, and find out about plants that grow locally. |
A four-lesson sequence:
- Warm-up with a real plant and presentation of the vocabulary with an illustrated dictionary.
- Groups set up the experiment and write predictions using a sentence frame.
- Observation and recording over two weeks (a table with drawings and words).
- Final task: each group explains its result to the class with a poster and the structure “The plant… because…”.
From the 4Cs to the CLIL pyramid
Oliver Meyer turned the 4Cs into a four-step planning procedure, the CLIL pyramid. The four Cs are the base, and planning climbs towards the final task:
- Choose the content and topic, the starting point.
- Prepare multimodal input: short texts, pictures, videos, real objects, diagrams. The more routes in, the more pupils get in.
- Design tasks that require thinking and interaction: classifying in pairs, predicting in groups, solving a problem. This is where the support is planned.
- Define the final product (a poster, an oral explanation, a simple report). The type of product decides which language and scaffolding will be needed.
In practice, it pays to think backwards: start with the final product and ask yourself what pupils will need to get there.
Common mistakes with the 4Cs
- Stopping at vocabulary. Learning ten words is not CLIL unless they are used to think and communicate something.
- Forgetting language for learning. Without structures to give opinions or explanations, pupils fall silent or switch to their home language.
- Treating Culture as an add-on. It doesn't need a separate lesson: one well-chosen connection within the unit is enough.
- Always asking at the first Bloom level. What's this? is necessary at the start, but if every question is about remembering, nobody has to think in English.
Further reading
- Coyle, D., Hood, P. and Marsh, D. (2010). CLIL: Content and Language Integrated Learning. Cambridge University Press.
- Meyer, O. (2010). Towards quality-CLIL: successful planning and teaching strategies. Pulso, 33, 11–29.
- Anderson, L. W. and Krathwohl, D. R. (2001). A Taxonomy for Learning, Teaching, and Assessing. Longman.
- Dalton-Puffer, C. (2013). A construct of cognitive discourse functions for conceptualising content-language integration in CLIL and multilingual education. European Journal of Applied Linguistics, 1(2).